An Astrologers Day by RK Narayan: the con man who told the truth
Some links on this page may be affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Written by
Navneet Shukla
Author
Navneet Shukla writes about how people think and how modern life shapes that thinking.
The Present Minds is where he explores it.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
The astrologer is a fraud who fabricates his predictions to survive in a bustling market.
The story explores themes of guilt, identity, and survival through the astrologer's past crime and its consequences.
A chance encounter with his victim forces the astrologer to confront his hidden past and deliver a life-altering lie.
Both men find freedom through deception, highlighting the complex nature of truth and forgiveness.
Narayan presents the story without moral judgment, emphasizing the ambiguous cost of truth.
GLOSSARY
Astrologer
A man who pretends to predict the future using traditional tools but actually fabricates his readings.
Guru Nayak
The man the astrologer attacked years ago, who confronts him seeking truth and revenge.
Malgudi
The fictional South Indian town where the story is set, representing an ordinary yet vivid marketplace.
Sacred Ash and Vermilion
Traditional markings worn by the astrologer to create an aura of authenticity and mysticism.
Cowrie Shells and Palmyra Writing
Tools used by the astrologer to simulate evidence of his supposed prophetic abilities.
Cheroot
A type of cigar whose brief illumination reveals Guru Nayak’s identity to the astrologer.
FAQ
Why is the astrologer considered a fraud?
The astrologer cannot actually read the stars or predict the future. He uses vague statements, traditional props, and the crowd’s beliefs to convince people to pay him, making his profession a performance rather than a genuine practice.
What is the significance of the astrologer’s encounter with Guru Nayak?
This encounter forces the astrologer to confront his violent past and deliver a fabricated truth that frees both men from their burdens. It shifts the story from a simple tale of deception to a complex exploration of guilt, survival, and forgiveness.
How does the story portray the theme of truth?
Truth is shown as complicated and costly. The astrologer tells a lie that brings relief to both himself and Guru Nayak, suggesting that sometimes truth can be more damaging than deception.
What role does the setting of Malgudi play in the story?
Malgudi, a fictional but relatable town, provides a vibrant and ordinary backdrop that reflects the everyday struggles and performances of its inhabitants, including the astrologer’s act of survival.
How does the story end regarding the astrologer’s guilt?
The astrologer shares his past with his wife and feels a sense of relief, but he neither confesses publicly nor seeks forgiveness. The story ends ambiguously, emphasizing ongoing internal conflict rather than resolution.
EDITORIAL NOTE
This piece is part of The Present Minds — essays on psychology, identity, and modern life.
An Astrologers Day by RK Narayan: the con man who told the truth
7 min read · 1,474 words
An Astrologer’s Day by RK Narayan is a story about a fraud.
A man who knows nothing about the stars. Who cannot read the future. Who sits under a tamarind tree every day in a busy market and tells people what they need to hear so they will pay him and go home.
He is very good at this. The sacred ash on his forehead helps. The vermilion. The cowrie shells and the Palmyra writing spread out in front of him like evidence. His eyes, Narayan tells us, sparkle with an abnormal gleam. His clients read this gleam as prophetic light. It is not prophetic light.
It is a man desperately scanning the crowd for one more customer before the lamps go out.
He is a fraud. He knows it. Narayan knows it. You know it.
And then the story does something extraordinary with this fraud. It gives him one night of perfect, accidental truth.
The Market at Dusk
The story takes place in a single evening. In Malgudi, that fictional South Indian town where Narayan set almost everything, a place so specific and so ordinary it could be anywhere.
The market is loud and alive. Vendors selling groundnuts. A cloth auctioneer creating din enough to pull in a whole street. Medicine sellers. Magicians. The usual democracy of a crowded Indian market where everything is available and nothing is quite what it claims to be.
The astrologer is part of this landscape. He belongs here among the other performers. He opened his bag and spread out his tools and became, for another day, a man who could see what the stars had decided about you.
He is almost done. The lamps are going out, one by one. The crowd is thinning. He is about to pack his cowrie shells and go home to his wife and child.
And then Guru Nayak sits down across from him.
The Stranger
Guru Nayak is not in a good mood. He does not believe in astrologers. He says so immediately.
He challenges. He wagers. He will pay good money if the astrologer can tell him something true. He is aggressive in the way that people are aggressive when they have been carrying something heavy for a very long time and they want someone to say something, anything, that will make it feel lighter.
The astrologer does what he always does. He tries vagueness. Flattery wrapped in mysticism. Is there a woman who dislikes you? Have you been treated unjustly? The usual tools.
Guru Nayak is not having it.
The astrologer is trapped. He cannot leave. The wager was made. He sincerely prays. Narayan includes this detail with perfect, quiet comedy. A fake astrologer, out of options, genuinely praying.
And then Guru Nayak lights a cheroot.
The brief flare of a match illuminates his face for one second. One second.
The astrologer goes very still.
He knows this face. He has been running from this face for years. Across hundreds of miles. Across a new name and a new town and a new life built entirely on the rubble of what he left behind.
He knows who is sitting across from him.
What He Did
Many years ago, when the astrologer was not an astrologer but a young man, he drank. He gambled. He got into bad company.
One night there was a fight. His knife found Guru Nayak’s chest. Guru Nayak fell. The astrologer threw him into a well and ran.
He ran so far and so fast that he became someone else entirely. He arrived in Malgudi with nothing. No money. No plan. He found work wherever it appeared. He married. He had a child. He put on sacred ash every morning and arranged cowrie shells on a mat and invented a life from scratch.
He thought he had killed a man. He had been living with this thought for years, the way you live with something you cannot speak and cannot escape. It was in the room with him every morning. It sat beside him under the tamarind tree.
A man can become anything if he is running from something big enough.
And now that thing is sitting across from him in the dark, asking for its fortune.
The Performance of His Life
The astrologer makes a choice. Not a moral one. A survival one.
He leans forward. He tells Guru Nayak things that only the man who attacked him could know. That he was stabbed. That he was thrown into a well. That he has been travelling south searching for the man who did it.
Guru Nayak is stunned. This stranger under a tamarind tree in a market in Malgudi knows the architecture of the worst night of his life.
Then the astrologer tells him the name.
Guru Nayak.
He says it the way an oracle says it. As if the stars whispered it. As if he pulled it from the cosmic record of all things.
Guru Nayak is completely undone. He is convinced. He presses forward with the question he has carried all this way.
Where is the man who did this to me?
The astrologer does not hesitate.
He died four months ago. Crushed under a lorry. In a town far from here. He died badly, which is what he deserved.
Go home. Never travel south again. Your life is long if you stay in your village.
Guru Nayak sits with this for a moment. He wanted revenge. He wanted the specific satisfaction of finding the man and making him face what he had done. That satisfaction will not come now. The man is dead.
But there is a different satisfaction available. The man died badly. Under a lorry. There is a justice in that, however cold.
He pays the astrologer. He leaves. He goes north, toward home, toward a village where he will spend the rest of his life believing his attacker is dead.
He is wrong. But Narayan never lets him find out.
Twelve and a Half Annas
The astrologer goes home. Late. His wife has been waiting, which is its own small story about what it is to be married to someone who keeps a secret this large.
He flings the coins at her. She counts. Twelve and a half annas. Guru Nayak promised a rupee and came up short by three and a half annas, and the astrologer is briefly, absurdly annoyed by this. The story gives him this moment of ordinary pettiness after the most extraordinary encounter of his life.
His wife is thrilled. She plans to buy jaggery and coconut for their child.
After dinner, the astrologer tells her. All of it. The village. The drink. The knife. The well. The years of believing he was a murderer. And then this evening. This night when the man he thought he had killed walked out of the dark and sat down across from him and demanded to know his own fortune.
A great load has gone from me today, he tells her.
He goes to sleep. Narayan ends it there.
What Narayan Knew
This is a story about guilt more than it is about astrology.
The astrologer is a fraud in his profession. He is not a fraud in his suffering. The guilt was real. The running was real. The life he constructed in Malgudi, the sacred ash, the cowrie shells, the daily performance of a wisdom he did not possess, all of it was built on one night of violence he spent twenty years trying to survive.
What the story does that is so quietly devastating is refuse to give him a clean ending.
He did not confess. He did not seek forgiveness. He told a lie to save himself and the lie happened to also be a kindness. Guru Nayak goes home believing his enemy is dead. He is free from the obsession of revenge. He will live longer and better for believing this.
Two men, set free by a lie. Neither of them knowing the full truth. Narayan offers no judgment on this arrangement. He just shows it to you and steps back.
Sometimes the truth would cost more than either side can afford.
The astrologer’s eyes sparkle with abnormal gleam.
You can read it as desperation. You can read it as guilt. You can read it as the particular brightness of a person who has survived something they should not have survived, and knows it, and has learned to call that knowledge by another name.
For twenty years he called it fear.
For one night he called it wisdom.
Maybe the difference was smaller than either name suggests.
Some links on this page may be affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Written by
Navneet Shukla
Author
Navneet Shukla writes about how people think and how modern life shapes that thinking.
The Present Minds is where he explores it.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
The astrologer is a fraud who fabricates his predictions to survive in a bustling market.
The story explores themes of guilt, identity, and survival through the astrologer's past crime and its consequences.
A chance encounter with his victim forces the astrologer to confront his hidden past and deliver a life-altering lie.
Both men find freedom through deception, highlighting the complex nature of truth and forgiveness.
Narayan presents the story without moral judgment, emphasizing the ambiguous cost of truth.
GLOSSARY
Astrologer
A man who pretends to predict the future using traditional tools but actually fabricates his readings.
Guru Nayak
The man the astrologer attacked years ago, who confronts him seeking truth and revenge.
Malgudi
The fictional South Indian town where the story is set, representing an ordinary yet vivid marketplace.
Sacred Ash and Vermilion
Traditional markings worn by the astrologer to create an aura of authenticity and mysticism.
Cowrie Shells and Palmyra Writing
Tools used by the astrologer to simulate evidence of his supposed prophetic abilities.
Cheroot
A type of cigar whose brief illumination reveals Guru Nayak’s identity to the astrologer.
FAQ
Why is the astrologer considered a fraud?
The astrologer cannot actually read the stars or predict the future. He uses vague statements, traditional props, and the crowd’s beliefs to convince people to pay him, making his profession a performance rather than a genuine practice.
What is the significance of the astrologer’s encounter with Guru Nayak?
This encounter forces the astrologer to confront his violent past and deliver a fabricated truth that frees both men from their burdens. It shifts the story from a simple tale of deception to a complex exploration of guilt, survival, and forgiveness.
How does the story portray the theme of truth?
Truth is shown as complicated and costly. The astrologer tells a lie that brings relief to both himself and Guru Nayak, suggesting that sometimes truth can be more damaging than deception.
What role does the setting of Malgudi play in the story?
Malgudi, a fictional but relatable town, provides a vibrant and ordinary backdrop that reflects the everyday struggles and performances of its inhabitants, including the astrologer’s act of survival.
How does the story end regarding the astrologer’s guilt?
The astrologer shares his past with his wife and feels a sense of relief, but he neither confesses publicly nor seeks forgiveness. The story ends ambiguously, emphasizing ongoing internal conflict rather than resolution.
EDITORIAL NOTE
This piece is part of The Present Minds — essays on psychology, identity, and modern life.
Leave a Reply